Integration architecture menu

When choosing an integration architecture for an organization, many different patterns are available. Antti Toivanen compared them to food. What would you like to have?

Integration Architecture Menu

Deliciously edible integration architectures are available today. New and old, good and bad architectural models are included. What kind of food micro service would it be? And how is SOA eaten? Who has already tasted the fresh mini service? Is it worth touching on the integration spaghetti?

Integration Spaghetti (1980-)

In spaghetti, the systems - meatballs in the picture - are connected directly to each other. It looks delicious at first and is cheap to implement if you don’t have to think about the belly aches that follow for IT and maintenance after cooking - that is, the project. Architects also know this as point-to-point integration architecture. In larger portions, it is impossible to ingest even partially, as removing one meatball (system) from the plate will result in the others rolling on the breast. Smells bad and is messy. "Cheap, but tastes unbearably bad"

Centralized meatball plate (1980-)

There are fewer unnecessary carbohydrates (connections) in a centralized architecture. Meatballs - or monolithic systems - stay in order and replacing them does not cause meatballs to roll into your arms. A traditional first integration dish from which gourmets will soon move on to the next dishes. A basic utility filler that also allows for centralized process control. However, centralized integration does not take away hunger as it does not scale. Centralized control is a good thing, centralized performance is not. In the picture, the middle meatball is called the integration platform. "A good appetizer but didn't go hungry"

SOA lasagna (2004-)

In this dish, services have been detached into generic layers. The lowest are the systems and the second lowest are the connectors of the integration platform connected to them. The integration platform publishes business functions on the next floor as reusable services that can be utilized by business solutions or processes. Excessive granules in the service layer often stick to the throat of the business. Made with too much piety, SOA lasagna is also expensive and slow to produce. "Expensive and came a little dazed"

Micro service sushi (2012-)

Business functions are enjoyed as completely uncoupled mouthfuls. Universal use is sacrificed above speed, and there are often several sushi services on the plate that are similar to each other. This dish does not include centralized control, but effectively takes hunger away at a reasonable cost. Often causes wonder, as few find the willingness to eat this dose. This is not served with ERPs and CRMs, but each mouthpiece - i.e. the micro service - owns its own business data - at least according to a strict interpretation. For some reason, it is often mixed into a mini-service style. A great choice when creating an entirely new service for which there are no ready-made applications. "Does this go with SAP? No."

Mini service tapas (2017-)

Very sushi-like in texture, but the edible pieces are enjoyed in suitably small whole. Works well with existing business systems. Some see this as the right way to make SOA architecture suitable mouthpieces without the fuss of lasagna. Delivered from the integration platform. "Works - very good for the price."

Nano service crab (20 ?? -)

Expensive specialty of culinary coders. After a terrible effort, there is not much to eat. Making a single call requires setting dozens of parameters with your own calls - this is usually only enjoyed with lots of Akvavit. Avoid by all means.

"I starved even though my fingers bleed."

What kind of architecture does your company eat?

Antti Toivanen
Director, Integration Services & RPAAuthor has over 22 years of experience in area of enterprise system integration and integration architectures.antti.toivanen@hiq.fi
Find out more
OPR-Finance Oy chose the frends integration platform
OPR-Finance Oy chose the frends integration platform to extend Legacy systems' lifetime, and accelerate the time between system development to production.
Kuopion Energia chose HiQ's Hyperautomation solution for its RPA challenge
Kuopion Energia has used HiQ’s integration platform FRENDS since 2018. The partnership strengthens to also cover RPA as a part of hyperautomation and support services.
Nurminen Logistics – Transitioning from a BizTalk server documentation to the Frends hyperautomation platform
Nurminen chose HiQ as its support partner for existing BizTalk integrations and to deliver new integrations and automations through the Frends hyperautomation platform
From integration to hyperautomation
Aalto uses pervasive iPaaS frends for hundreds of APIs, integration processes and AI based hyperautomation.
S-Pankki Integrates with Frends iPaaS
S-Pankki implemented integrations, process automation and APIs with Frends. Development costs were 1/3 compared to previous implementation.
Eltel's modern process automation
Automated work order processes bring cost savings, reliability and transparency
Helen integrates with FRENDS
Helen has implemented hundreds of integrations and APIs with FRENDS Hybrid Integration Platform.
Turku Enegria integrates with Frends
With Frends integration platform, Turku Energia has agile integration development and has modified their old integrations to be more effective.
Häme University uses FRENDS to integrate
Häme University of Applied Sciences manages its integration with FRENDS eiPaaS
City of Lohja automates processes
HiQ's FRENDS enterprise integration platform-as-a-service automates critical processes of the city of Lohja
Arc Technology - HR Integrations
HiQ Integration Platform FRENDS provides integrations between Arc Technology's in-house, customer, and third-party information systems.
Viestilehdet chose the FRENDS eiPaaS
Viestilehdet Oy and HiQ Finland have entered into an agreement to provide FRENDS integration platform.
HiQ brings savings to Raisio and enhances business flexibility
Raisio successfully rolled out the frends integration platform to streamline business and management processes
MTV and HiQ enter strategic partnership
HiQ's agility and professionalism have met MTV's rapidly changing needs.
Integrations generating business for Neve
HiQ’s ICC directs the development, maintenance and production operations of Neve's integration solutions, taking into account its business needs.
Taksini - a modern transportation solution
A digital platform to support Lähitaksi's business needs utilised by easy-to-use and customer-friendly mobile application.
Hamina Energy chose frends as its new integration platform
Hamina Energy chose HiQ’s integration platform frends to bring efficiency to its operations.
Oras trusts the Frends Integration platform
Efficient integration saves money, increases transparency and improves the management of potential errors.
ISS introduced a new Frends integration environment as part of the ERP system upgrade project
ISS Palvelut is one of the largest private employers in Finland, and the leading facility services company. HiQ and ISS have partnered since 2013.

About this project

Antti Toivanen
Director, Integration Services & RPAantti.toivanen@hiq.fi+358 40 715 1935